April 23, 2008
The most significant decision handed down yesterday dealt with search and seizure issues.
The Supreme Court affirmed Wednesday that police have the power to conduct searches and seize evidence, even when done during an arrest that turns out to have violated state law.The unanimous decision comes in a case from Portsmouth, Va., where city detectives seized crack cocaine from a motorist after arresting him for a traffic ticket offense.
David Lee Moore was pulled over for driving on a suspended license. The violation is a minor crime in Virginia and calls for police to issue a court summons and let the driver go.
Instead, city detectives arrested Moore and prosecutors say that drugs taken from him in a subsequent search can be used against him as evidence.
"We reaffirm against a novel challenge what we have signaled for half a century," Justice Antonin Scalia wrote.
Scalia said that when officers have probable cause to believe a person has committed a crime in their presence, the Fourth Amendment permits them to make an arrest and to search the suspect in order to safeguard evidence and ensure their own safety.
Now this gets into the whole issue of whether actions taken in good faith by police, even when there was an error, violate the Constitution. After all, the search was standard procedure pursuant to an arrest, and it appears from my reading o this somewhat vague wire service report that the officers did not realize that an arrest under the circumstances was a violation of the standards set by the state. A string of cases dating back to the early 1980s made this result no surprise -- after all, police officers cannot be expected to be fortune tellers regarding future appeals court decisions.
And before our friends on the left start intoning the usual rhetoric about fascist police states, please notice that even Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the ACLU's mouthpiece on the Supreme Court, ruled that there was no problem with the search.
Posted by: Greg at
10:00 PM
| Comments (20)
| Add Comment
Post contains 371 words, total size 2 kb.
Posted by: paris hilton sex at Wed Oct 28 20:48:12 2009 (g/2aA)
Posted by: kim kardashian ray j at Fri Oct 30 02:47:36 2009 (jbwz6)
Posted by: lindsay lohan hot at Mon Nov 2 21:08:21 2009 (iN3lv)
Posted by: megan fox fhm at Mon Nov 2 21:09:05 2009 (iN3lv)
), jessica alba butt, 272908, lucy pinder, 409, Posted by: holly madison pictorial at Tue Nov 3 03:26:02 2009 (nfqXF)
Posted by: holly madison pictorial at Tue Nov 3 03:26:45 2009 (nfqXF)
Posted by: paris hilton sex at Tue Nov 3 03:28:06 2009 (nfqXF)
Posted by: emma watson sex at Fri Nov 6 08:34:05 2009 (FX1tN)
Posted by: carmen electra fucking at Fri Nov 6 20:06:44 2009 (2WsTU)
DD, Posted by: paris hilton video at Fri Nov 6 23:06:39 2009 (lHNPL)
Posted by: britney spears ass at Sat Nov 7 05:02:59 2009 (9+2/u)
Posted by: katy perry sexy at Sat Nov 7 05:04:05 2009 (9+2/u)
Posted by: megan fox fhm at Sat Nov 7 05:04:38 2009 (9+2/u)
(, lindsay lohan hot, :-[[, free kim kardashian sex tape, koo, kim kardashian naked, talqc, Posted by: free kim kardashian sex tape at Sat Nov 7 05:05:12 2009 (9+2/u)
Posted by: megan fox fhm at Sat Nov 7 05:05:45 2009 (9+2/u)
Posted by: kendra wilkinson playboy at Sat Nov 7 05:06:18 2009 (9+2/u)
, miley cyrus nude, 394, miley cyrus pics, 8472, kelis sextape, yhvl, jessica alba exposed, 661, Posted by: katy perry sexy at Sat Nov 7 05:06:52 2009 (9+2/u)
Posted by: miley cyrus pics at Mon Nov 9 07:42:44 2009 (SLjxe)
Posted by: lindsay lohan sex tape at Mon Nov 9 23:27:47 2009 (okPwx)
Posted by: paris hilton video at Thu Nov 12 04:11:06 2009 (aaiQb)
21 queries taking 0.0114 seconds, 49 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.