July 20, 2006

Black Perps, White Vic. Never Mind -- No Hate Crime.

After all, just because one of the criminals admits that the victim was chosen because he was "a goofy-looking white boy" doesn't make it a crime based upon bias.

Prosecutors on Wednesday stood by their contention that the three teens who allegedly beat and robbed a 14-year-old Beverly boy won't be charged with a hate crime -- even though one of the trio told police they picked the boy because he was "a goofy-looking white boy."

They instead charged the three black teens with aggravated battery and robbery, both felonies. Bond was set Wednesday at $300,000 for Micha Eatman, 17, and two 16-year-olds were in juvenile detention.

Meanwhile the condition of the victim, Ryan Rusch, was upgraded from critical to serious.

Chicago Police said after the incident Sunday they were investigating it as a robbery. But Tuesday, in light of the suspect's statement in court, the case was assigned to the department's civil rights section.

Now tell me -- what would happen anywhere in this country if three white kids beat a black kid into a coma and one of them made a public statement that they picked the victim because he was a "goofy-looking black kid"? Hate-crime charges would be filed in an instance, and every self-aggrandizing member of th e"civil rights leadership" would be on the scene, demanding government action and a cut for their organization.

Now as I've said often enough in the past, I don't believe in hate-crime laws. I don't think they can ever be applied in a neutral fashion. This case proves my point.

Posted by: Greg at 11:18 AM | Comments (2) | Add Comment
Post contains 280 words, total size 2 kb.

1 I was about to comment on this... but actually, I'm going to write about this soon on my blog on the Chron, so I'm just commenting to invite you to jump into the fray over there in a few days! (The short version is that there are some good intentions and inherent problems in hate crimes, but also some general confusion about the thinking that led to them.)

Sorry to be a tease but I have more thoughts on this than will fit in a comment.

Posted by: John at Thu Jul 20 12:22:00 2006 (YId1A)

2 I was about to comment on this... but actually, I'm going to write about this soon on my blog on the Chron, so I'm just commenting to invite you to jump into the fray over there in a few days! (The short version is that there are some good intentions and inherent problems in hate crimes, but also some general confusion about the thinking that led to them.)

Sorry to be a tease but I have more thoughts on this than will fit in a comment.

(By the way - can I politely suggest you consider a different web host? Your blog is offline more than any other I read! Just FYI, in case you didn't realize it was happening.)

Posted by: John at Thu Jul 20 12:49:31 2006 (YId1A)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
7kb generated in CPU 0.0049, elapsed 0.0122 seconds.
21 queries taking 0.0089 seconds, 31 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
[/posts]