April 26, 2006
I've once again been struck by the ignorance that abounds in the media regarding the Constitution and what it means when it uses certain terms. It is as if there is an intentional rejection of the history of certain words and phrases, in the interest of getting a story.
Take this comment from none other than Bob Novak, who should know better (after all, he covered the Constitutional Convention along with Helen Thomas)
The U.S. Constitution prohibits a religious test for public office, but that is precisely what is being posed now. Prominent, respectable Evangelical Christians have told me, not for quotation, that millions of their co-religionists cannot and will not vote for Romney for president solely because he is a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. If Romney is nominated and their abstention results in the election of Hillary Rodham Clinton, that's just too bad. The evangelicals are adamant, saying there is no way Romney can win them over.Romney is well aware that an unconstitutional religious test is being applied to him, but he may be seriously minimizing the problem's scope as limited to relatively few fanatics. He feels the vast majority of conservative voters worried about his faith will flinch at the prospect of another Clinton in the White House. But such a rational approach is not likely to head off a highly emotional collision of religious faith and religious bias with American politics.
No, Bob, there is no "unconstitutional religious test" being applied to Romney, based upon what you have written in this column.
As used in the COnstitution, the term "religious test" refers to oaths or actions that are required of a citizen BY GOVERNMENT before they might hold office or receive some government benefit. Such tests existed to one degree or another in most of the colonies prior to the Revolution, and were common in England into the 1800s. Many of them were directed at Catholics, and required that the officeholder take an oath that they rejected the authority of the pope and certain "false and pernicious doctrines" which were part of the Catholic faith. Quakers and Baptists were also often targetted by such oaths. The prohibition, therefore, is one on GOVERNMENT ACTION, not private action.
Unless I missed something in the Novak piece, no such religious test is being required by government.
What is happening, for better or for worse, is that questions are being raised in some minds about voting for a Mormon, given that faith's divergence from certain historical doctrines of the Christian faith. Now I've never heard such questions raised in the Republican or religious circles in which I run, but the media keeps telling me that they are. But assuming that they are, that does not constitute a violation of the prohibition on religious tests -- for the Constitution cannot and does not dictate what factors may be considered by individual citizens when they enter the voting booth, as the individual vote of a citizen is most decidedly NOT a government action.
Which is not to say that I approve of those who would let Romney's religion enter into their calculations. If it goes on, I find it offensive -- just as I did when Ted Kennedy raised the religious issue against Romney when he was the GOP nominee for Senate.
Posted by: Greg at
10:46 PM
| Comments (92)
| Add Comment
Post contains 584 words, total size 4 kb.
Posted by: girls at Mon May 12 07:11:06 2008 (eqBoU)
Posted by: girls at Mon May 12 16:28:29 2008 (J4oqY)
Posted by: sex at Mon May 12 17:31:52 2008 (EbyuF)
Posted by: sex at Mon May 12 21:44:13 2008 (d/L9s)
Posted by: sex at Mon May 12 23:23:05 2008 (Ox+cY)
Posted by: free at Tue May 13 07:04:14 2008 (sCNIf)
Posted by: gay at Tue May 13 07:25:26 2008 (6TsL+)
Posted by: sex at Tue May 13 17:17:51 2008 (GpmcM)
Posted by: young girls nude at Tue May 13 22:01:24 2008 (kV5Ls)
Posted by: sex at Tue May 13 23:51:16 2008 (qss1B)
Posted by: erotica password sapphic at Wed May 14 02:04:14 2008 (PMU7s)
Posted by: avril lavigne naked at Wed May 14 02:42:44 2008 (YRAe6)
Posted by: sex at Wed May 14 05:03:36 2008 (73OYW)
Posted by: pron game at Wed May 14 06:55:45 2008 (T1xie)
Posted by: sex at Thu May 15 08:48:32 2008 (Yxi2t)
Posted by: sex at Thu May 15 08:56:02 2008 (Yxi2t)
Posted by: sex at Thu May 15 15:00:39 2008 (PVHDN)
Posted by: sex at Thu May 15 20:20:22 2008 (EbyuF)
Posted by: nude at Thu May 15 20:47:43 2008 (BwUEY)
Posted by: nude at Thu May 15 21:38:53 2008 (oVeHf)
Posted by: sex at Thu May 15 22:12:40 2008 (SgwDB)
Posted by: sex at Thu May 15 23:11:32 2008 (vpTAP)
Posted by: sex at Thu May 15 23:36:45 2008 (CUCMG)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 00:29:34 2008 (kmXU6)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 01:54:33 2008 (PoLnB)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 02:38:56 2008 (/vq+n)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 05:53:03 2008 (cb/48)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 14:57:48 2008 (IT81A)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 16:35:06 2008 (hrUkp)
Posted by: girls at Fri May 16 17:02:27 2008 (hrUkp)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 17:42:30 2008 (cb/48)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 20:09:32 2008 (4TZLj)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 20:24:45 2008 (2qITw)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 20:36:42 2008 (2YMIw)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 21:19:51 2008 (BTrxq)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 23:43:13 2008 (qrcXQ)
Posted by: sex at Fri May 16 23:49:30 2008 (qrcXQ)
Posted by: sex at Sat May 17 04:41:11 2008 (eUWOG)
Posted by: sex at Sat May 17 05:32:51 2008 (PYap+)
Posted by: sex at Sat May 17 05:40:02 2008 (BTrxq)
Posted by: nude at Sat May 17 09:25:43 2008 (Hn+3r)
Posted by: sex at Sat May 17 12:39:37 2008 (FvJyp)
Posted by: sex at Sat May 17 15:15:36 2008 (BTrxq)
Posted by: sex at Sat May 17 15:37:34 2008 (0CbJi)
Posted by: bed wetting at Sat May 17 22:00:59 2008 (8gvns)
Posted by: doa girls at Sun May 18 00:34:33 2008 (gHGKN)
Posted by: aeonflux at Sun May 18 04:51:24 2008 (0CbJi)
Posted by: anal orgasm at Sun May 18 05:09:18 2008 (+5+cp)
Posted by: little penis at Sun May 18 06:46:22 2008 (+hj6f)
Posted by: ass and tits at Sun May 18 07:57:58 2008 (+hj6f)
Posted by: ass and tits at Sun May 18 07:57:58 2008 (+hj6f)
Posted by: ass and tits at Sun May 18 07:57:58 2008 (+hj6f)
Posted by: biggest loser at Sun May 18 09:31:56 2008 (0dGyl)
Posted by: biggest boobs at Sun May 18 12:00:19 2008 (tacUb)
Posted by: geocities web builder at Sun May 18 17:03:40 2008 (XOzKq)
Posted by: 2006 auto show at Sun May 18 17:14:18 2008 (+hj6f)
Posted by: free pron at Sun May 18 17:22:08 2008 (53LxL)
Posted by: female orgasms at Sun May 18 18:10:08 2008 (BTrxq)
Posted by: 15 year old models at Sun May 18 20:27:53 2008 (VXKZD)
Posted by: sex in the shower at Sun May 18 23:23:39 2008 (UeGoP)
Posted by: nipple jewelry at Mon May 19 00:10:37 2008 (msZZI)
Posted by: teen nudism at Mon May 19 02:04:57 2008 (FvJyp)
Posted by: gay boy at Mon May 19 02:06:05 2008 (hhL+U)
Posted by: fuck me hard at Mon May 19 04:40:59 2008 (BwUEY)
Posted by: www bangthumbs com at Mon May 19 05:14:42 2008 (PoLnB)
Posted by: lita nude at Mon May 19 06:09:25 2008 (PoLnB)
Posted by: nudist nudism beach girls at Mon May 19 10:08:03 2008 (hhL+U)
Posted by: holly madison nude at Mon May 19 11:25:29 2008 (OuIX3)
Posted by: sex at Mon Jun 2 12:52:19 2008 (nLxkm)
Posted by: sex at Mon Jun 2 16:31:34 2008 (uLCvR)
Posted by: sex at Mon Jun 2 23:37:38 2008 (P/AO/)
Posted by: sex at Fri Jun 13 11:16:12 2008 (eqXe7)
Posted by: sex at Fri Jun 13 21:29:59 2008 (lAYUP)
Posted by: sex at Thu Jun 19 06:10:23 2008 (uNoTD)
Posted by: sex at Thu Jun 19 12:59:04 2008 (Rveng)
Posted by: sex at Thu Jun 19 14:50:50 2008 (ktWBD)
Posted by: sex at Fri Jun 20 10:16:39 2008 (YczRf)
Posted by: sex at Fri Jun 20 11:19:27 2008 (UGTOF)
Posted by: sex at Fri Jun 20 20:58:55 2008 (tBYnf)
Posted by: autotrader ca at Sat Jun 21 11:03:09 2008 (SYKdB)
Posted by: vaginal discharge at Sat Jun 21 17:22:59 2008 (scLSs)
Posted by: sex at Mon Jun 23 04:35:33 2008 (CfDWF)
Posted by: pornno at Mon Jun 23 20:06:07 2008 (YczRf)
Posted by: jenna elfman nude at Wed Jun 25 14:03:29 2008 (eTRsk)
Posted by: gay youth at Mon Jun 30 00:55:16 2008 (5b8CI)
Posted by: incest sex stories at Sat Jul 5 17:58:43 2008 (G56ux)
Posted by: hit em up at Thu Jul 24 04:36:11 2008 (Ikg5S)
Posted by: sex at Tue Sep 30 04:06:11 2008 (nff1F)
Posted by: sex at Wed Oct 1 03:22:25 2008 (dfHdk)
Posted by: sex at Thu Oct 2 07:26:11 2008 (dzT3v)
Posted by: sex at Wed Oct 8 12:23:22 2008 (cSclm)
Posted by: sapphic at Tue Dec 2 23:22:41 2008 (7YJxU)
21 queries taking 0.0205 seconds, 121 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.