July 26, 2006

I Missed This Whine

And I have to tell you, reading it makes me convinced that the author, American University graduate student Sui Lang Panoke, does not belong in graduate school.

Is access to graduate education in America exclusively for the upper class?

As a first-year graduate student struggling to make ends meet, I believe the answer is yes. In my experience, searching for funding to pay the extensive costs of my higher education has been an upward climb leading only to dead ends.

I am a single mother who qualifies for the maximum amount in federal aid for graduate students. But this amount barely covers my tuition; paying for housing, books and living expenses is up to me.

I have no college fund, trust or inheritance. I don't independently qualify for private student loans because I lack the substantial credit or employment history that is required, and I do not have the luxury of having a willing and eligible co-signer. Furthermore, I can work only part-time jobs while in school; otherwise I would not qualify for child-care assistance.

Well, you could do what I did -- get a graduate assistanship and WORK your way through graduate school. While I did get some assistance from my parents, i don't come from wealth -- my father was a just-retired military officer and my mother a housewife.

I can't help but notice the little detail you include that reveals the true problem you have. It is single parenthood. Had you kept your knees tightly together, you wouldn't have a child and you would be able to make your way through graduate school on a significantly tighter budget. But you don't want to focus on that issue, because it might mean that some of the blame for your financial issues might bounce back on YOU, dear.

But of course, you see yourself as a victim of a government that has lost sight of what you view as its proper role.

We are failing to redistribute the wealth in America, and the divide between the upper and lower classes is widening. It's clear that a federal need-based grant program for graduate students must be created. This would help level the playing field by creating access to graduate programs for students -- access based on merit and ambition rather than economic resources.

Sorry, girlfriend, but the role of the government is not the redistribution of wealth. Since you are seeking a degree in public administration, you might be familiar with a document called the United States Constitution. If you read it, you might note that it sets out a number of tasks for the federal government -- and redistributing wealth is not one of those tasks. So you clearly don't know enough to even be in graduate school in your field -- and might I add, it certainly explains why you haven't gotten any of the few scholarships you have deigned to apply for. After all, while you have ambition, you clearly fall short in the merit department.

So forget continuing as a full-time student at your high-dollar private university. Consider attending a public university -- one with a lower price tag and more financial aid opportunities.

Or perhaps you should recognize that you made a poor choice to try to balance graduate school and single parenthood -- and go out and get a job to support yourself, instead of expecting one more public dolar handout.

Posted by: Greg at 03:08 PM | Comments (3) | Add Comment
Post contains 575 words, total size 3 kb.

1 What is it with our generation whose priorities are so out of whack? As soon as Sui had a child what SHE wanted mattered no longer.

This woman has a serious problem. But there's one person who has a worse problem than she does and that's her kid. For baby I'll pray; for the mom I'll pray that she soon sees the light. This whiner who desires "access" based on "merit and ambition" only has ambition to get someone else to pay her way.

Bob

Posted by: BPD at Wed Jul 26 23:14:47 2006 (mSuB/)

2 Why stop at redistributing the wealth so that she can afford graduate school? Why not redistribute enough that she doesn't have to? Personally, given her major, I would be more willing to pay her to stay out of school.

Posted by: Jason at Thu Jul 27 01:20:59 2006 (Y2Bw/)

3 Jason has a good point.

Just replace "Access to graduate education" with any other desirable but expensive commodity available in America and the fallacy of the whole thing is apparent.

Ben

Posted by: Ben at Thu Jul 27 04:35:21 2006 (8GHW6)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
8kb generated in CPU 0.004, elapsed 0.0108 seconds.
21 queries taking 0.0078 seconds, 32 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
[/posts]