September 11, 2005

Why Show These?

I've always questioned the showing of graphic photos of the dead to children. Yeah, I know that they were a staple of driver's education -- but they were not local photos. If you show local photos, you risk something like this.

A 12-year-old girl saw her father's remains in a gruesome photograph shown during a presentation by police warning teenagers about the dangers of drunken driving.

The girl's mother, Marla Cabbage Higginbotham, said her daughter was traumatized by the experience at her middle school last month in which she saw her father lying in a pool of blood with a crushed skull and mutilated face and torso.

She said the family did not know he had been drinking when he died.

An attorney representing the mother and daughter sent a letter to the Knox County law director's office calling for an investigation.

"Why are we showing 12-year-olds mutilated dead bodies when they can't even drive a car for four more years?" attorney Gregory P. Isaacs said Friday. The police "are good people with good intentions who have made a terrible, terrible mistake."

Police officers say the names of the victims about to be shown and ask if any students knew them. They called out the name of William F. Cabbage before showing pictures of the wreck.

The girl did not recognize his name because she knew her father as Lynn Cabbage.

I'm sorry -- this is unacceptable. Shouldn't there have been family permission before using the photos in any presentation? Shouldn't there have been family permission before the kids were subjected to the photos?

Posted by: Greg at 02:31 PM | Comments (2) | Add Comment
Post contains 270 words, total size 2 kb.

1 Uhh...they shouldn't have shown ANY 12 year old photos of dead people...period. If that were a movie, it'd be adults only. Why is it that the presentation of it taking place in a school changes it any? Are the photos really necessary? I had no such photos when I was in driver's training, and I still got the message...a car is a dangerous tool that is to be treated with respect. When it isn't treated with respect, people die.

I would and will lose my mind if my kids are shown this stuff. It's not the school that'll have to deal with the fallout, it is my wife and I who will. I've got enough to deal with right now, thanks, and don't want them to be exposed to something like that without me being there to explain it to them and help them understand the context in which it's presented.

As far as this poor girl goes...my heart goes out to her. As far as I'm concerned, it was abuse to show her the pictures - she's TWELVE YEARS OLD for cripes sake! - it was worse that it was her father.

Bartleby

Posted by: Bartleby at Tue Sep 13 05:31:24 2005 (lkCzp)

2 How about high school? I was in the 10th grade driver's ed (many eons ago) and was shown a video-tape of mutilated bodies (most teens and young drivers) in a post-car crash at the scene. One was a car full of teens who tried to beat a passing train. Guess who won?

Although I wasn't exactly sickened, but the guy in front of me had his head bobbing up and down about 1/2 way thru until he fainted.

Certainly, the film do raise a level of awareness among those who think they're immortal.


Posted by: mcconnell at Wed Sep 14 11:38:23 2005 (o58ig)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
7kb generated in CPU 0.0592, elapsed 0.1174 seconds.
21 queries taking 0.0972 seconds, 31 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
[/posts]